Justice Now

J U S T I C E   N O W:
You Be the Judge

Here are the results of this poll:

Who was right? In whose favor do you think the court decided - T.L.O. or the school?

ABCDE
Response# of votes% of vote
AWhen a student is at school, school rules are the law. They have the right to search a student's possessions any time they decide it's necessary to protect the rest of the students.159529%
BIf this student wasn't involved in drug dealing then she wouldn't have minded if the school searched her purse.191135%
CIt's okay for a school to search a student's possessions in some situations.154728%
DThis was an 'unreasonable' search, so whatever was found in the student's purse should not be used as evidence against her.1002%
EThis is a total outrage! A student should have the freedom to carry anything in a purse, pocket, or backpack. No nosy teacher or principal has the right to pry into her belongings.962%
Total:5450 100%

What happened in court?

The Juvenile Court said the school could search T.L.O.'s purse. Why? Because a school official can  search a student if...

"...there is a reasonable suspicion that a crime has been committed or there is reason to believe the search is necessary to maintain school discipline or enforce school policies."

Bottom line. Since the vice principle suspected  T.L.O. was smoking in the bathroom he could open her purse. Once the purse was open, the rolling papers, etc., gave him a reasonable suspicion  that she was selling drugs.

Case closed? No... T.L.O. appealed to the New Jersey Supreme Court.

How'd the higher court rule?

New Jersey Supreme Court said the search of T.L.O's purse was not reasonable and therefore her rights had been violated. They said the contents of her purse had nothing to do with the crime she was accused of... smoking cigarettes.

Bottom line. Just because the vice principal didn't believe T.L.O. when she said she didn't smoke cigarettes did not justify  the search. No one gave him any information about there being cigarettes in her purse. And even if he had been justified in opening her purse, the evidence he saw of drug use did not justify the extensive "rummaging" through her things that followed. The New Jersey Supreme Court overturned the Juvenile Court's ruling.

Case closed? No... The School appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court and in 1985 the case came before the highest court.

What was the final ruling?

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that it was a legal search.

Case closed? Case closed!


See what others have to say,
or post your own opinions on this topic!

 

Check out other "You be the Judge" Cases:

 


J U S T I C E
N O W

Home | Me, Myself, & I | Relationships Unlimited | Justice Now | Spaceship Earth | The Gallery
Hey Terra! | Been There Stories | Solutions In Sight | The Story | Polls & Activities
Discussions | Search | Site Map | About Us | About Annie Fox

©1997-2024 Electric Eggplant
last updated January 25, 2023
This site hosted on HostGator.com